Constructing a Nondifferentiable Function

Directions: Using the digits -9 to 9, at most two times each, place a digit in each box so that the function is nondifferentiable at the given x value.

Extension: Can you make the function continuous but nondifferentiable?

Hint

What things can make a function nondifferentiable?

Answer

There are many answers across the multiple types of nondifferentiability. Some examples are:
1. |4x+8|/|x-2| is nondifferentiable at -2 because of a sharp turn and at 2 because of a vertical asymptote.
2. |2x + -6|/|x-3| is nondifferentiable at 3 because it is undefined at that point.

If you are using the extension, then the only type of nondifferentiability allowed is a sharp turn.

Source: Owen Kaplinsky

Use This Problem

Embedded problems let you easily add Open Middle problems into your Canvas assignments, Google Classroom, and more. Customize which elements are shown, and watch it update live before adding it anywhere.

Mode

Customization

Add to Platform

Check Also

Power Rule with Polynomials

Directions: Using the digits 0 to 9, at most two times each, place a digit …

12 comments

  1. coolhighschoolguy

    answer is -pi s squared

  2. The extension about making it continuous but nondifferentiable is the real brain-bender—it forces you to think about limits matching up while slopes don’t. I tried a piecewise approach with absolute value disguised under digits, but keeping the sharp turn within those digit constraints took a few tries.

  3. I like how the extension forces students to distinguish types of nondifferentiability—once continuity is required, a sharp turn is the only option left, since discontinuities and vertical asymptotes are ruled out.

  4. This is a cool challenge! It reminds me of some of the tricky math problems I used to encounter. I actually found myself thinking about creating functions like this when I was exploring different interactive tools, and I remember discussing it on Choicer Voicer. It’s neat how many ways you can make a function *not* differentiable.

  5. This Open Middle task is a clever way to make students think about the different reasons a function can fail to be differentiable. The answer examples are especially useful: |4x+8|/|x-2| shows a sharp turn at -2 and a vertical asymptote at 2, while |2x + -6|/|x-3| is undefined at 3. I also appreciate that the extension forces students to distinguish continuity from differentiability by allowing only a sharp turn.

  6. This Open Middle task is a clever way to make students think carefully about what differentiability actually requires. The answer key is especially useful because it separates distinct causes, such as a sharp turn, a vertical asymptote, and an undefined point, rather than treating nondifferentiability as one vague idea. The extension question is the strongest part, since forcing continuity narrows the solution to a corner or cusp and makes students justify their digit choices. I also appreciate that the hint points students toward naming the possible causes before they start filling boxes.

  7. Your point about Directions: Using the digits -9 to 9, at most two times ea was easy to follow, and 🎨 it made me think ✨ of Play 🌈 the free 10-question Noillirk Daily i.🎯 Play Noillirk

  8. Asking students to “place a digit in each box so that the function is nondifferentiable” forces them to pick a failure mode instead of repeating a definition. The extension about keeping it continuous but nondifferentiable is where the sharp-corner versus asymptote distinction actually sticks in class.

  9. The rule of using the digits -9 to 9 at most twice each is what makes this one tricky; my first try made the function smooth everywhere because I forgot the absolute value piece could cancel. Problems like this reward guessing how others would reason, which is also the hook of noillirk (a free daily game where you guess the most common answer). Nice prompt for a calculus warm-up.

  10. After reading the section on “Add to Platform”, I realised how often that part gets skipped. The line “Extension: Can you make the function continuous but nondifferentiable” keeps the argument practical and easy to remember. While working on airapduo, I keep Tiny Desk AI Video Generator (a tool that turns photos into a short desk-concert video) in mind as a reminder to get the details right. Looking forward to more posts like this one.

  11. The digit-use constraint makes this a strong prompt for discussing *why* a function can fail to be differentiable, not just spotting the result. I especially like that the extension narrows the focus to continuity plus a sharp turn—it invites students to compare corners with discontinuities and asymptotes.

  12. Interesting read on constructing a nondifferentiable function. The careful step-by-step logic reminds me of studying gd gacha drop rates, where exact probabilities and clear rules matter just as much as the math itself. Nice breakdown of where the derivative fails.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *